Watch on the CBS website (can be difficult with low-speed internet), or YouTube (part 1, part 2) and then take the time to thanks CBS for having given the settlement issue a fair hearing.
Author: issandr
Links for January 28th
Links from my del.icio.us account for January 28th:
- SarahPAC – Sarah Palin’s Official PAC – Maverick Hockey Mom 2012! I like how the map of the USA in the front page has Alaska in the middle, hovering over Wyoming, Utah and Colorado.
- Qu’est-ce que le Hamas ? – Les blogs du Diplo – A short history of Hamas by Alain Gresh.
- IAEA chief ElBaradei cancels BBC interview over Gaza aid row – Haaretz – Israel News – More anger at Beeb decision not to air Gaza fundraiser.
- ‘New EU president is a true friend of Israel, a Zionist prince’ – Haaretz – Israel News – Caech Zionist drives pro-Israel EU diplomacy.
- “Casanegra”, film-vérité sur Casablanca, dévoile la face sombre du Maroc – Afrique – Le Monde.fr – More on Moroccan hit movie Casanegra.
- Gulfnews: Children found with bullets lodged in their head – Was there deliberate, systematic targeting of Gaza children by IDF soldiers: "Cairo: Doctors operating the only brain-scanning machine at an Egyptian hospital near Gaza have been almost overwhelmed by the number of Palestinian children arriving with bullet wounds to the head."
- Daily News Egypt – IN FOCUS: THE BROTHERHOOD AND THE GAZA CRISIS – Khalil Anani's take on the MB behavior's during the Gaza Crisis, which he says suggests political naiveté and an attachment to anti-Western mobilization of Hassan al-Banna's day rather than more pragmatic mobilization towards Egyptian reform.
Obama’s TV appearance
– Very good on the Obama team to have made this move, which was necessary, so quickly.
– It repairs some, but only some, of the damage caused by his silence on Gaza.
– The choice of Arabiya was most probably a decision to appeal to the Saudis, have Obama underline the importance of their Arab Initiative which has been snubbed by Israel and the US under Bush.
– Nonetheless Arabiya is problematic – this is the channel dubbed Hibriya (The Hebrew One) because of its coverage of the Gaza crisis and that generally defends the views of Riyadh, Cairo and other problematic US allies. This confirms that Obama will not, like Bush since 2006, go against Egypt and Saudi on domestic issues and there won’t be a rethink of the US relationship with these. But if you thought that would happen, you’re stupid.
– Should Obama have gone to Jazeera instead? Perhaps not, for both domestic reasons (the criticism he would expose himself to, even if unwarranted) and because there are genuine US complaints about Jazeera. But at some later point, he should go to Jazeera – especially if it is to pitch a major conflict resolution initiative in the region. At the end of the day, despite its bias, Arabiya is the number two pan-Arab stations. (In many countries, like the rest of the world, Arabs actually watch their national TV stations most.)
– Obama’s next move should be to disband al-Hurra. It’s a useless waste of money.
– Obama’s line that the US should “start by listening” will be taken (along with the phone calls) with enormous pleasure by Egyptian diplomats, among others, who felt that the advice of Arab allies was ignored under Bush.
– I am also disturbed at why an American president would say Israel’s security is “paramount” – as in more important than anything? Why should it be? Why not say it’s a “red line” in the grand old style of Arab leaders?
– What this says (as much as this kind of interview can say anything deep) is that the Obama approach compared to Bush, for now, is more active and tough on Iran, same on Israel but more involved on peace process, Forward Agenda for Freedom is dropped because conflict resolution and managing Iran is more important, and greater attention to communication issues.
The professional analysis is of course at Marc Lynch’s blog, here and here. Juan Cole has the interview and transcript. Update: Another take here.
Regarding the issue of Hillary Clinton’s “Israel’s right to defend itself” comment, I think the US should stop using this formulation. Why not instead say, “did Hamas expect Israel to do nothing as it launched rockets?” Obviously I’d like to see some serious concern, repeatedly voiced, for the IDF’s behavior in Gaza and the disproportionality of the conflict.
Links January 26th to January 27th
Links from my del.icio.us account for January 26th through January 27th:
- U.S. Navy ordered to release Iran weapons ship – US Navy conducting searches of Iranian ships in Egyptian territorial waters.
- Bloomberg.com: Mubarak Risks Losing Lead Role in Gaza Talks as Criticism Rises – Would Egyptian failure in its mediation efforts doom a Gamal presidency?
- IkhwanWeb | Egypt’s intelligence blackmails wounded Palestinians to tell about Hamas – Reports on Egyptian intelligence torturing/interrogating Palestinians being treated in Egypt are surfacing.
- Almasry Alyoum | The Butane Gas Cylinder – Magdi Gallad's column in Masri al-Youm illustrates some of the recent problems with shortages of butane gas cylinders – among the most subsidzed item in Egypt's huge subsidy program.
- Le Figaro – International : Souleiman, l’homme qui sait parler à Israël et au Hamas – Profile of Mar Suleiman.
- Israel stymies French push to lift European boycott of Hamas – Haaretz – Israel News – French-Israeli battle over change of policy on Hamas isolation.
- Egypt persecutes Muslim moderates – International Herald Tribune – Quranists got an op-ed in IHT. I don't like their use of the stupid analogy "Islamic Reformation" though.
- VirtualGaza | Break the Information Blockade – Google Earth overlay magic over Gaza.
- Egyptian chronicles: On this day please become our shield not our enemy – On the origins of Egypt's Police Day.
- Lebanon’s Daily Star shut down – International Herald Tribune – Daily Star's gone bust? Too bad.
- Democracy Now! | Noam Chomsky: Obama’s Stance on Gaza Crisis “Approximately the Bush Position” – Still early, Noam. But it's true we've seen nothing new so far.
- Among Egyptians, mixed feelings over Gaza – Yahoo! News – This war really brought into the open the divisions in Egypt over Hamas and the Palestinians more generally.
- TelQuel : Le coup de poing Casanegra – Casanegra, Morocco's hit movie.
- FT.com / Middle East / Arab-Israel conflict – Israelis display ‘grim satisfaction’ – War crimes as group therapy: "Whether through pride, relief or even a sense of triumph, there is no doubt that the Gaza conflict has at last made Israelis feel better about themselves, their leaders and their army."
L’Humanite account of cold-blooded murder of children in Gaza
En mars dernier lors d’une énième incursion dans la bande de Gaza, l’armée israélienne avait fouillé les maisons puis avait continuer son chemin, vers Jabaliya. La famille Abed Rabbo (d’où le nom du lieu), occupait l’ensemble des petits immeubles qui se trouvaient là. Quand l’offensive a commencé, les Abed Rabbo étaient sur leurs gardes, mais pas plus inquiets que ça. Ce qui peut sembler étrange pour qui ne vit pas le quotidien de ces Palestiniens, soumis au bon vouloir des Israéliens. En mars dernier, par exemple, ils avaient fait une incursion dans la bande de Gaza en passant par le hameau. Ils s’étaient contentés d’une fouille des habitations et avaient passé leur chemin. « C’est pourquoi tout le monde pensait que ça allait être la même chose cette fois-ci », explique Khaled, 30 ans. Lui se trouvait avec sa famille au rez-de-chaussée d’un immeuble dans lequel vivaient 27 personnes. Le 7 janvier, en milieu de matinée, les Israéliens sont arrivés. Ils ont installés un poste militaire. Les chars se sont mis en position derrière des buttes de sable alors que par hauts-parleurs ils intimaient l’ordre aux gens de sortir.
« Comme nous habitions au rez-de-chaussée, nous sommes sortis les premiers », raconte Khaled, la voix tremblante. « J’étais avec ma femme, nos trois filles et ma mère. J’avais un drapeau blanc. Sur le char, il y avait deux soldats. L’un mangeait des chips, l’autre du chocolat. On est resté comme ça pendant plus de 5 minutes, alignés. Personne ne nous disait rien. On ne savait pas quoi faire. Soudain un soldat est sorti du char. Il était roux et portait les papillotes des religieux. Il a tiré sur ma petite fille de 2 ans, Amal. Ses intestins sont sortis de son ventre. Puis il a visé en rafale celle de 7 ans, Sohad. Ma femme s’est évanouie. Il a tiré sur ma mère ». Summum du vice chez ce soldat, il n’a pas tué Khaled. Une ambulance se trouvait à proximité. « Ils ont fait descendre le chauffeur puis ont écrasé le véhicule avec un char », soutient Khaled Abed Rabbo. Les deux petites filles, Amal et Sohad, sont mortes. La troisième est grièvement blessée. Avec son frère et sa femme, Khaled les emmène, ainsi que la mère. Ils prennent la route non sans essuyer les tirs de snipers embusqués dans les maisons qui jouaient à leur faire peur en visant à côté. « Au rond-point, un homme a voulu nous aider avec sa carriole. Il s’appelait Hadnan Mekbel. Les Israéliens l’ont tué ainsi que son cheval. » Khaled sort son portable et montre ses filles dans un linceul. La troisième est dans un hôpital en Belgique. Elle est tétraplégique. Sa femme est dans un état de choc psychologique permanent Khaled ne peut pas oublier. Il revient tous les jours devant sa maison détruite. « C’est toute ma vie, mes souvenirs. Je vois mes enfants jouer autour de moi », dit-il. « C’était la maison du bonheur ».
Quick summary if you don’t speak French: Abed Rabbo’s family had dealt with Israeli soldiers before, in March 2008 during a brief Israeli incursion. Nothing had happened then, and they just expected a search of their house this time around. The Israelis made him and his family line up and wait as tanks lined up across them. Then a red-haired soldier sporting Haredim long locks came out of a tank, shot his 2-year old daughter Amal (“her guts spilled out of her stomach”) and then his 7-year-old daughter Sohad. They then destroyed a nearby ambulance, and when they found a man with a horse cart to help them, the man and his horse was shot. According to Rabbo, he and his wife (who is still under shock) were left alive and their daughters targeted and kept from medical care on purpose, to teach them a lesson. His third daughter was also shot (and will probably be disabled for life) and is receiving medical care in Belgium.
For a decade now there has been rising concern in Israel in the growing strength of the religious right among the armed forces, especially the transition from para-military youth movements to the IDF some young religious Israelis make, especially if they are from lower-income groups.
From the comments, more testimonies here.
Links January 25th to January 26th
Links from my del.icio.us account for January 25th through January 26th:
- Black Death ‘kills al-Qaeda operatives in Algeria’ – Telegraph – Terrifying – AQIM rumored to be experimenting with bubonic plague.
- Sic Semper Tyrannis : Dennis Ross and the “Jewish People Policy Planning Institute” – Pat Lang says maybe Dennis Ross should not have a board position in a Jewish Agency institution (note: the JA is an organization dedicated to bringing Jews to Israel).
- Hamas to Abbas: End talks with Israel before any reconciliation | Middle East | Jerusalem Post – Hamas pulls out a whopper.
- Daily News Egypt – BLOGGER HEAVILY FINED IN RARE CASE OF CORPORATE LIBEL – First libel case against blogger in Egypt.
- Marc Lynch’s Foreign Policy blog – This is the RSS link for Abu Aardvark's new home. I finally updated my newsreader. I hate change. Down with change!
Links for January 25th
Links from my del.icio.us account for January 25th:
- Top Anglican priest raps BBC: Gaza appeal is not ‘Hamas asking for arms’ – Yet again confirming (and I am not religious at all) the Church of England is pretty much the pinnacle of human spiritual achievement. More tea, vicar!
- Israel minister warns Hamas PM over Shalit
(AFP) – Very interesting how the Israelis put Shalit back on the table immediately after the end of Cast Lead. Do they need a political asset for the upcoming elections since they've ended up with the strategic status quo in Gaza? - LRB · Henry Siegman: Israel’s Lies – Once again, LRB provides the definitive commentary on Gaza from the highbrow English mags.
- LRB · Paul Myerscough: Diary – A very nice article on poker. That's the LRB for you: great on the Middle East, great on poker. What else could you possibly want?
- TPMCafe | Talking Points Memo | What’s Love Got To Do With It (pt.1) – I have great respect for Josh Marshall of TalkingPointsMemo.com as a blogger, publisher and journalist. But his comment here that being in favor of suspending US military aid to Israel is tantamount to support the genocide of Israelis is not only ridiculous but deeply insulting. He owes an apology, and perhaps a rethink of his extremely tribalist (a word he likes to use often) view of the conflict as a Jewish-American. (The piece linked here is by Bernard Avishai, btw, read down the comments for Josh's incredible statement.)
- People: Mark Regev mauled on Channel 4 News again | News | The First Post – Israeli govt spokesman gets his comeuppance from the real TV journos in UK.
Waltz with Bashir
Links for January 24th
Links from my del.icio.us account for January 24th:
- Grande Finale of Inauguralpalooza: God, Gays and Gaza – The Sleuth – I saw Ben Affleck speak on the issue of Congo on TV the other day (he is involved with the UN on this.) He is surprisingly articulate and obviously interested in foreign affairs. Plus Armageddon is the ultimate American movie of all time. So welcome to Israel-Palestine, Ben, it's the south Boston of the Middle East.
- Diplomacy after the Gaza war | Now get back to making peace | The Economist – Analysis of post-Gaza for Fatah and Hamas, and prospects for reconciliation.
- Obama acts fast on Mideast, but substance familiar | Reuters – Jonathan Wright analyses lack of changes in Obama's Mideast policy, Arab disappointment.
- Tramway de Jérusalem : Veolia sanctionné en Suède – Les blogs du Diplo – French corp. Veolia loses big Swedish contract in part due to opposition to its role in Jerusalem subway – go swedes!
- BBC under pressure to reverse decision not to air Gaza aid appeal | Media | guardian.co.uk – Govt, Muslim and aid associations to protest against Beeb.
Links for January 24th
Links from my del.icio.us account for January 24th:
- FT.com / Comment / Opinion – Saudi patience is running out – Humble civil servant Turki al-Faisal sends warning to Obama.
- Notes from Palestine – "I met a mother who was at home with her ten children when Israeli soldiers entered the house. The soldiers told her she had to choose five of her children to 'give as a gift to Israel.' As she screamed in horror they repeated the demand and told her she could choose or they would choose for her. Then these soldiers murdered five of her children in front of her. "
- Revolution, Facebook-Style – Can Social Networking Turn Young Eygptians Into a Force for Democratic Change? – NYTimes.com – A so-so piece on April 6 and Egyptian bloggers.
- Iran’s Postmodern Beast in Gaza – The Atlantic (January 5, 2009) – The reliably Zionist Atlantic (remember James Fallows' article on Muhammad al-Dura, or Jeffrey Goldberg's rantings) has Gaza as "the western edge of the Iranian empire."
- Israel indicts two Iran TV journalists for reporting on Gaza ground invasion – Haaretz – Israel News – Sounds like bullshit excuse to go after Iran-affiliatied journos.
- Out of the rubble – The National Newspaper – Mouin Rabbani writes Mahmoud Abbas' obituary: "In his initial response Abbas laid responsibility for the conflict at Hamas’s doorstep, in one stroke reducing his role to that of a factional leader opportunistically siding with his cousin against his brother. More to the point, he unleashed the full power of his security forces against his own people. Not to prevent a Hamas coup in the West Bank, or even attacks against Israel, but to suppress pro-Palestinian demonstrations of the kind permitted even within Israel."
- Ibrahim: Al-Qaeda wants to Hit the US Again and turn Obama into another Bush – Egyptian Gamaa says Qaeda wants to attack US soon in revenge for Gaza.
- Jamal’s Propaganda: 6 degrees of Myopia – New Orascom deal for Lebanon mobile network, signed by Hizbullah ally, forgets Orascom has business interests in Israel. Will Sawiris get swindled in the Sham again?